Giving References Gets Risky

caution-454360_1280Giving a work reference for a former employee can be risky.  This is particularly true when the request regards a less-than-satisfactory employee, and you speak spontaneously and without prior thought.

The safest response you can give when you are asked for an employee reference is this: The employee’s date of employment with your company. If the employee was full-time or part-time. A description of the position the employee held. The employee’s salary range.

Can you be honest in what you tell? If you stick to the topics above, being honest will not be a concern. But if you tell a prospective employer the employee was rude and a constant source of irritation to you,  you may be expressing views which could lead to defamation charges.

Also, you can’t just refuse to give out any information about former employees and avoid all possible problems. Even this strategy isn’t risk free. Some courts have held the refusal to give a reference for a former employee while providing references for other employees is itself defamatory.

In addition, failure to tell a prospective employer truthful, but negative, information about a former employee can lead to “negligent referral” and “negligent misrepresentation” lawsuits. Negligent referral and negligent misinformation lawsuits assert a former employer has failed to disclose complete and accurate information about former employees. The argument is made that the former employer’s failure to provide truthful, negative information led to a hiring that resulted in damage or harm to the new employer or to the employees or customers of the new employer. Examples of damaging and harmful acts include theft, violence and sexual assaults.

Consider the following in developing a reference policy:

  • Require a terminating employee to give you written permission to respond to a reference check.
  • Ask that requests for reference checks be made in writing.
  • When responding to a request, put your comments in writing. This protects you from being misquoted later.
  • Put a reference response system into place and make sure that only the people you authorize are handling requests for employee references.
  • Keep any information and responses you provide job-related.

Before you adopt a reference policy, check your state’s laws concerning references. The laws on this can vary from state to state. Some states place a restriction on what type of information can be released without the employee’s written authorization.

Also, many states have shield laws giving legal protection to employers when they provide truthful, work-related information about former employees to prospective employers.

[NOTE: Information and guidance in this story is intended to provide accurate and helpful information on the subjects covered. It is not intended to provide a legal service for readers? individual needs. For legal guidance in your specific situations, always consult with an attorney who is familiar with employment law and labor issues.]


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s